Remix.run Logo
summarybot 2 hours ago

Authoritarian versus Libertarian? Really?

tomrod 2 hours ago | parent | next [-]

Substitute 'Communitarian' and 'Classical Liberal' if you find the common political compass terms too charged.

MarkusQ 2 hours ago | parent [-]

Since when are Socialists considered Classical Liberals?

It's not that the labels are charged, it's that they are nonsensical unless you look at them from a very narrow bespoke perspective, where "things I like" go on one side and "bad things" go on the other. Objectively (or even from any other biased perspective), it's rubbish.

tomrod an hour ago | parent [-]

They aren't. You flipped them, not sure if intentionally or by accident.

MarkusQ 22 minutes ago | parent [-]

So are you saying Xi Jinping is the Classical Liberal and Bernie Sanders is the Comunitarian? Or are you saying it's the other way around?

(For clarity: I didn't "flip" them, I'm saying that they are both Communitarian and neither is a Classical Liberal.)

MarkusQ 2 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

And the two most "Libertarian" politicians listed (Sanders and Sánchez) are both avowed Socialists...WTF?

I really think this says more about the biases of whoever came up with it (or their sources) than anything about reality.