Damn well trying to enforce an "obviously no bugs" rule in a language runtime would mean zero progress in language runtimes.

We certainly wouldn't have gotten to where we are with runtime and compiler quality and performance if we had damn well tried to enforce such a rule

▲

nasretdinov 3 hours ago | parent [-]

IMO the very minimum requirement should be that you've demonstrated effort to reduce unnecessary complexity of the problem. Sure, some problems are complex enough that there might not exist an obvious solution, yet usually after a while once you're familiar with some topic the existing solutions do start to appear obvious. If they're not I'd argue we're doing something very very wrong

▲

pizlonator 3 hours ago | parent [-]

Adding concurrency to JavaScript definitely falls in the "complex enough" category

So does basically any feature or optimization in a JS runtime

▲

nasretdinov 3 hours ago | parent [-]

I think it's also worth distinguishing _problem complexity_ and _solution complexity_. The problem might be really really hard (and it very obviously is in the case of adding multi-threading to JavaScript). But it does not mean that the solution has to be hard to understand. It doesn't mean that any average PHP developer (I can say that, I started with PHP) should be able to verify the correctness of the patch, but for a person who is well familiar with the area there shouldn't exist areas they can't understand.

Look at the description of your own Fil-C: it focuses on clarity of explanation of how it works, and it actually does make sense (and, hopefully, works well enough too). Compare that with the pull request sent here. I'll wait

▲

pizlonator 3 hours ago | parent [-]

The solution to concurrency in JS is hard to understand and I would expect even hardened JSVM folks (me included) to be super confused by it

▲

nasretdinov 2 hours ago | parent [-]

I think you're underselling your own level of intelligence Fil. If even you would be confused by an implementation (and you're the author of the concept) what chances do you think this PR has to actually work correctly?

	▲	pizlonator an hour ago \| parent [-]
		Lots of tests