Remix.run Logo
armada651 2 hours ago

Who determines the specs?

Pooge 2 hours ago | parent [-]

Specs are business requirements. Choosing a programming language is not a business requirement; it's a technical one.

swiftcoder 10 minutes ago | parent | next [-]

> Choosing a programming language is not a business requirement; it's a technical one.

Technical decisions like this have to take into account a lot of factors outside of just the language itself.

Is the language you want to use easy to hire for? Will we have to pay a premium for engineers with a specialised background in the language? Do all our 3rd party dependencies maintain SDKs for the language? Do libraries that meet various certifications we might need (i.e. FIPS) exist for the language?

Something like Typescript or Java is going to win out over Rust/Erlang/FP-of-your-choice on a number of these criteria.

shakna 2 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Platforms are often part of the business requirements.

If you're working on SAP or Salesforce, the language decisions are already made for you. If you're integrating with an existing Electron runtime, then you'll be using something in the JS family, like it or not.

Someone 2 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

> Choosing a programming language is not a business requirement; it's a technical one.

Not solely. The business will have reasons to stay on a mainstream language, for example because

- it offers better guarantees for hiring maintainers in the future

- it has a higher likelihood that security issues will be fixed rapidly for free

- LLMs are better at maintaining code written in it

jpollock 2 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

The programming language can have definite business impacts. It can impact hiring, salary costs (if the skill is rare), ramp-up costs (if it needs to be taught), etc.

Even bus-factor comes into it.

Pooge an hour ago | parent [-]

Software engineering is an important skill to recruit for. Too many times I see "Java Developer"... Like, do they only know Java and are absolutely incompetent when it comes to something else?

I don't even want to recruit or be recruited with such a title.