Remix.run Logo
evanjrowley 3 hours ago

I've never been a fan of Ubiquiti's proprietary solutions, but this might actually be one product that I can be enthusiastic about.

MiracleRabbit 3 hours ago | parent | next [-]

They are getting better.

After a long time they introduced ONVIF into their camera products which basically opened it to everyone.

cassianoleal 3 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

I've recently been convinced to implement a Unifi stack for my home network. I got a Cloud Gateway, a 10G switch and a couple WiFi APs.

The Cloud Gateway will be sold or given away. It's utter crap. I'm now building an OpenWRT container on IncusOS as my Internet gateway/router.

The switch is meh. It's easy to admin, which is nice - though I'm having to run UnifiOS on another container on said IncusOS.

The APs are fine. Decent power and the central administration with the switch is actually quite nice.

If I knew everything I know now, I wouldn't have bought any of those but they will do for now.

mohaine 3 hours ago | parent | next [-]

I love by Dream Machine Pro. Seems to just work and keep everything up to date. I have it running my security cameras as well and it has been pretty much bullet proof.

What needs do you have for a router that the Cloud Gateway is missing or is bad at? A PiHole equivalent is about all I can think I'm missing.

9x39 25 minutes ago | parent | next [-]

+1 for Dream Machine Pro. Own one at home and have stretched them pretty far in SMB environments.

I use it with 8 APs in a mesh and a few switches, all UI, and it just works. I also have a lot of success helping out some local SMBs by setting up UI for them.

cassianoleal 3 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

IPv6 support is basic at best. The zone-based firewall is very prescriptive and limited. ACL stuff is not great. To increase the MTU of the physical interface connected to the ISP I would need to hack a systemd unit that did it on boot (I either need it at 1508 so the PPPoE interface uses 1500, or I need to MSS clamp it and have it effectively reduced to 1492). Initial configuration requires the device to be connected to the Internet.

There were a few other niggles, and in the end I just found it easier to do what I need on OpenWRT.

m-s-y 3 hours ago | parent [-]

just genuinely curious about your MTU use case and why this is required...?

SparkyMcUnicorn 3 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

I really like the DM Pro and have it deployed to an office of about 50 people. It's a pretty no-fuss solution and fairly simple to manage.

For my personal setup, I decided to go with OPNSense and I couldn't be happier. Much more control, at the cost of being a little more hands on.

I think the best (rough) comparison here is MacOS vs Linux (or more accurately in this case, FreeBSD).

mpeg 3 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I went with eero and really wish I'd gone with unifi

Apart from the shitty software and basic features either missing or locked behind a monthly cost, the network itself is not bad at all, I get 600-700mbps on wifi throughout the house and have my servers wired on 2.5gbe

But the one thing I really thought I was buying into by choosing an amazon brand was ease when it came to buying upgrades, and yet I ended up having to buy extra hardware (like the wired gateway) from ebay and sellers in the US as amazon does not sell their own hardware everywhere

AbsurdCensor 2 hours ago | parent | next [-]

I started with Unifi and it's been pretty great overall. I've integrated all the cameras into Home Assistant, it's all local, and can bridge with HomeBridge so it all shows up and plays nicely with HomeKit as well. Rock solid and very few complaints.

wccrawford 2 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

I've had standalone routers, Eero Pro, Google Wifi, TP Link Deco, TP Link Omada, and probably some I'm forgetting. They all had something that just enraged me.

I finally bought a Unifi and I'm very happy with it so far, 6 months in. There's a few things I haven't tried, like rebooting it while it doesn't have an internet connection (I'm looking at you, Deco!), but so far my big complaints are that it's opinionated about the initial setup, and setting up a static IP for a device that isn't connected yet is a serious PITA. I had devices on my old system that I didn't want to have to change IPs (because the computers talk to each other) and that was not easy. If I had to do it again, I'd probably just let it do what it wants and deal with changing all those configs to the new IPs.

FWIW, I just have it as a router, and my Wifi is still some of my expensive standalone Asus wifi routers acting as just access points. I didn't see a point in replacing them when they were working great as APs.

threecheese 3 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

What were your constraints and how were they not met? Looking to buy the same, Dream Machine specifically.

robinvdvleuten 3 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

What do you know now then?

cassianoleal 3 hours ago | parent [-]

See the answer I gave to the sibling comment.