So if they say "idk Claude did it", what would you write in the PR review box?

REJECTED: Engineer does not understand what they wrote.

A teammate that can't write (or at least, can't explain) "their own code"

Actively drags down the morale and productivity of their team (because everyone is getting flooded with AI slop PR's)

AND costs far too much money relative to everyone else doing actual work? (token usage)

By god they sound like management material