Remix.run Logo
bko 3 hours ago

> Hallucinations and poor guidance are still a regular day-to-day issue that makes it impossible for me to trust agents with anything.

I often hear this. Can you give me a question where a major LLM hallucinates or provides poor guidance? Reproducible would be great

Just a question to stump it.

atomicnumber3 3 hours ago | parent | next [-]

Just today, the LLM based auto-review that my company enabled for all PRs edited my PR description to confidently assert that I had added a new RPC. I had not. I deleted code and nothing else. Nothing was added. The RPC it claimed I added did not exist.

This is a common occurrence.

al_borland 2 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

LLMs are nondeterministic, so it’s impossible to make something 100% reproducible. Even if it has an issue, it might do it in a different way. If it’s well publicized, they’ll patch that very specific example, but the foundational issue is still there (like counting the R’s in strawberry).

I still regularly run into the issue where it just makes up API endpoints, CLI commands, or add flags that simply don’t exist.

I also regularly ask it things and it gives me a bad answers, so I push back, and it says something to the effect of “you’re right, I didn’t consider that, let me look at that more”… then tells me the exact opposite of the previous response.

Or it “thing X has never happened”, and I ask what about <insert example>, and it goes to look it up and says, “oh, thing X actually did happen.”

I run into this daily. Multiple times per day. How can I trust a system like this? Are people just blindly accepting what the LLM says as truth? Is that why people think it’s good?

jagged-chisel 3 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

> Reproducible would be great

Wouldn’t it be great? I’m still waiting for reproducibility from LLMs.

bko 3 hours ago | parent [-]

Can you reproduce irreproducibility?

Give me a question which the LLM answers vastly differently on runs.

I keep hearing how it's dumb and wrong but no one ever shares the chat or prompt

jagged-chisel 2 minutes ago | parent | next [-]

Yes. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48420769

uxhacker 3 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

Try this with ChatGPT or GROK or Claude

How many days of the week contain the letter d?

The answer I get with ChatGPT, and Grok is 3 and 6 with Claude.

jagged-chisel an hour ago | parent [-]

I just used ChatGPT only, twice. Web interface in a Firefox private window, and in a Chrome incognito window. I asked them both the identical question "How many names of the days of the week contain the letter D?"

In Firefox I got 6. In Chrome I got 7. LLMs are not even self-consistent.

I have the screenshots if anyone cares.