Remix.run Logo
kingleopold 2 hours ago

can all of you say that competitor to photoshop made by AI native teams is impossible in 10 years?

bayindirh 2 hours ago | parent | next [-]

Yes, because UX is not an exact science.

Aperture discontinued, one of the engineers in the team built a replacement, yet it's not Aperture.

Pixelmator did the "impossible", Apple bought them instead of doubling down on their talent and resources.

Small yet powerful editors like Acorn and Camera Bag Pro has no practical competitors in their spaces.

Technical problems are easy, yet humans and things involving human interaction is hard. You can't solve non-tangible problems by remixing tangible bits of code.

Heck, even Photoshop revamped a couple of dialog boxes, and a number of people got angry, because it behaves slightly differently and throws decades of muscle memory out of the window, and that costs people considerable amount of time.

j16sdiz an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I think AI will do, like, 90% of them in 10 years. With the last 10% takes much longer (15? 20?).

I am upset with the fact that we are accumulating code debit faster than ever. In the most optimistic view, we could pay off those debit in around 10+ years (assume somebody care pay the money to buy token to clean up those).

That meant we need to suffer 10+ years of low quality code and software.

j16sdiz an hour ago | parent [-]

--

recently, I tried to make AI write Long Form Novel.

The first problem I see is, AI have no idea what is important.

Teaching them when and where to use active voice/passive voice, who needs to be the subject, when to change the focus is just impossible. They love to add comparison and contrast on something least important. They love to use long list of adjective, which is unrelated to the context in current story chapter, just because those adjective are in my character file.

Understanding which problem is important in when and why is something hard.

I think same problem would appear in larger computer programs.

rhplus 2 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

The competitors to Photoshop right now are promoted image manipulation tools, not another menus-and-layers based Photoshop clone.

ares623 2 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

it won't matter by then. There won't be any artists to use them!