I wish people would stop generating stuff they don't understand only to forward it to someone who does. Something about that really rubs me the wrong way.

May I remind you that this is Timothy Gowers. He says he doesn't understand, but he most certainly has far greater capacity than most to detect complete junk from a maybe plausible argument. His colleague is even better able to judge this, hence why he sent it to him.

Also if he did send me complete junk, I would still parse it for multiple days to see what is there.