Remix.run Logo
roenxi 2 hours ago

> I’m highly doubtful about this - it seems to be an excuse to disestablish the BSA, rather than a genuine basis for the decision.

The title of the piece is "Government to disestablish the BSA" and the domain is .govt.nz. I think it only fair to point out they're being very upfront that this is their excuse for disestablishing the BSA.

> NZ has been relatively resistant to populism and partisanism in the past, partially because we have a watchdog to make the media all play nice.

It's an island [0] that has a smaller population the 2 largest cities of the nearest mainland, Australia. A substantial chunk of the country is uninhabitable due to mountains (and Orcs, based on what I've seen of it). It'd be quite challenging for the NZ population to rift into partisanship, they don't have enough people or space. If you look at somewhere like the US, it tends to be populations the size of NZ locked in a fight with other populations the size of NZ for who wants the right to tax the other.

What is NZ supposed to fight over, whether the factories go on north island or south island? It isn't that big a deal. I suppose no fight more serious than one over trivia, but really.

[0] Islands?

bombcar 2 hours ago | parent [-]

Venice was a hotbed of political intrigue in the olden days and had half the population of NZ.

roenxi 42 minutes ago | parent | next [-]

I suppose. Although if NZ manages the sort of vigour and industry of Venice back in the day I am going to move there.

bombcar 13 minutes ago | parent [-]

It's amazing reading history, about a huge city that totally affected the course of a major war, manufacturing and logistics hub - open it up and look inside: "Population 10,000."

Roman Army at it's peak: 450,000 men.

Walmart: 2.1 million

(Cue reddit arguments about Roman Army vs Walmart)

piva00 an hour ago | parent | prev [-]

I don't think the republic of Venice ever had 2 million people, what time period are you referring to?

bombcar 14 minutes ago | parent [-]

Wikipedia reports it peaked at 2.5m - "16th century estimate".