| ▲ | solid_fuel 3 hours ago | |
This is such a weird comment. > Since the times GPT-2 was reimplemented inside Minecraft - its quite obvious LLMs are just math. This was obvious since LLMs were first invented. They published papers with all the details, you don't need to see something implemented in Minecraft to realize that it's just math. You could simply read the paper or the code and know for certain. [0] > math is the only area of human knowledge with perfect flawless reductionism, straight to the roots Incorrect, Kurt Gödel showed with his Incompleteness Theorems in 1931 [1] that it is impossible to find a complete and consistent set of axioms for mathematics. Math is not perfectly reducible and there is no single set of "roots" for math. > It was build [sic] that way since the beginning, This is a serious misunderstanding of what mathematics is. Math is discovered as much as it is built. No one sat down and planned out what we understand as modern mathematics - the math we know is the result of endless amounts of logical reasoning and exploration, from geometric proofs to calculus to linear algebra to everything else that encompasses modern mathematics. > And because of that flawless reductionism, complexity adds nothings to the nature of math things, this is how math working by design This sentence means nothing, because math is not reducible in that way. > so it can be proven there are no anything like consciousness simply because conciousness [sic] was not implented [sic] in the first place, only perfect mimicry. Even if the previous sentence held, this does not follow, because while we are conscious the current consensus is that LLMs are not and most AI experts who are not actively selling a product recognize that LLMs will not lead to human-equivalent general intelligence. [3] [0] https://github.com/openai/gpt-2 [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/G%C3%B6del's_incompleteness_th... [2] https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/think/article/mathem... | ||