> HN is filled with people who think engineering productivity is simple to measure.

I think the prevailing (correct) consensus is that developer productivity is actually very hard to measure, and every time it is attempted the measure is immediately made a target making the whole thing pointless even if it had been a solid measurement- which it wasn't.

IDK where you're getting the idea here that measuring productivity of anyone who isn't a factory worker is easy.

▲

hyperpape a day ago | parent | next [-]

I do not think it is easy, like I said. I am saying other people are acting like it’s easy.

See the second comment on this article. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47976781

See @emp17344 responding to me.

▲

dijit a day ago | parent [-]

That second comment isn't making that statement though.

It's saying that: cost vs revenue is something we can see.

If I buy a plow for $2,500 and it enables growth of $5000, then arguing "the plow was expensive" is a moot point.

It doesn't make any argument about measured productivity, only investment vs return.

▲

mulmen a day ago | parent [-]

The difficulty in measuring productivity is the attribution. How do you know the new plow enabled growth?

▲

dijit 18 hours ago | parent [-]

because trend and changing fewer variables.

▲

mulmen 18 hours ago | parent [-]

If you could actually prove that you wouldn’t be posting it on HN, you’d be shopping for a mega yacht.

	▲	dijit 5 hours ago \| parent [-]
		What? Theres hundreds of MBAs who know this and it’s used to squeeze the workforce. Thats why its the default thinking from them, because it works sometimes. I think you missed something.

▲

tomjakubowski a day ago | parent | prev [-]

Is it easy to measure a factory worker's productivity? It would seem surprising and interesting if every job's productivity is hard to measure except for one particular kind.

	▲	dijit a day ago \| parent [-]
		Any job where there's a definable output can be measured. Factory workers are one type. Others might be farmers; if they're able to yield x tonnes of valid crops out of y acres.