Remix.run Logo
Remix clone Hacker News
new | show | ask | jobsGithub
▲ throwaway2037 17 hours ago

    > one-party state of Singapore (technically democratic, in practice it functions like a recallable monarchy).
This is untrue. It would be more accurate to say that the same party has been in power since independence from the UK. Each election in the last 30 years has slowly moved the needle -- fewer and fewer of seats held by the majority party (PAP). I guess there will be a non-PAP prime minister in the next 20 years. Sure, it doesn't look like other democracies, but please don't call it one-party. Also: See Japan. Many outsiders just don't understand democracy in Japan and try to impose their worldview on a different type of democratic system.
▲mothballed 17 hours ago | parent [-]

I'll yield that it isn't a pure one party state. There is some room for difference of opinion whether you want to characterize it as one or not.

But let's not play the bullshit and borderline xenophobic, ad-hominem attack that it's just "outsiders" who "just don't understand." Or try and distinguish that it's people 'imposing their worldview' (something every human does no matter what they are arguing).

But don't take my word for it. Read what Lee Kuan Yew had to say himself[0]:

  The PAP represents the broad middle ground in society and attracts the best and brightest people into Government, LKY said last night.  He therefore did not see a two- or multi-party system emerging in Singapore soon.
Ah yes, good ol LKY, the outsider who just doesn't understand Singapore, and with such a non-Singaporean 'viewpoint' that he had quite popular support (even if you want to argue it is a minority, it was widespread enough as to be valid enough to be considered one valid and widespread Singaporean point of view). Calling it not a two or multi-party system, leaving quite obviously his assertion is that it's a one-party system.

This and other points, documented by Yeo Lay Hwee (Senior Fellow, Singapore Institute of International Affairs) , who even if she flip flops between suggesting Singapore is a one-party state, lists quite a few reasons why it is a reasoned viewpoint from an understood observer [1].

[0] https://eresources.nlb.gov.sg/newspapers/digitised/article/s...

[1] https://library.fes.de/pdf-files/iez/01361007.pdf