Remix.run Logo
gchamonlive 3 hours ago

> This is of course assuming you take AI-generated code unchanged.

How much code do you need to change in order for it to be original? One line? 10%? More than 50%?

That's arbitrary and quite unproductive convo to be honest.

ninkendo 2 hours ago | parent [-]

> That's arbitrary and quite unproductive convo to be honest.

Yeah but that’s what the legal system ostensibly does. Splitting fine hairs over whether a derived work is “transformative” is something lawyers and judges have been arguing and deciding for centuries. Just because it’s hard to define a bright red line, doesn’t mean the decision is arbitrary. Courts will mull over whether a dotted quarter note on the fourth bar of a melody constitutes an independent work all day long. It seems absurd, but deciding blurry lines are what courts are built to handle.

gchamonlive 21 minutes ago | parent | next [-]

I see lawyers come here time and again, and it's very nice to see their points. But are we lawyers here? I'm not. If you are sorry about that, but if not my point stands.

stvltvs an hour ago | parent | prev [-]

Because at the end of the day, someone has to own the code, so some lines have to be drawn no matter how arbitrary they seem.