> Can't find a Waymo article about this, but Lyft and Uber (let alone trad taxis) also do this. I'm not sure that this is a particularly autonomous-car-shaped sin.

It depends on expectations. If the pitch is (and, let's face it - it is) that automs will be less violent, then this is a problem. If we're OK with them just adopting the existing levels of misery and death visited upon our communities by cars, then the upside is far less than we've been sold.

▲

tjwebbnorfolk 4 hours ago | parent | next [-]

I want to hear how you equate "misery and death" with "unloading a passenger in the bike lane for 30 seconds".

I can't tell if you intend this a real analogy or if you are overcome with rage when thinking about motor vehicles

▲

ok_dad 4 hours ago | parent | next [-]

Pulling into the bike lane for 30 seconds causes bikers to have to unsafely pull around the car, possibly causing accidents. In some cities and lanes you may be endangering dozens of bikers during the 30 seconds.

I had to commute by foot for two years into a city, and I have to say I understand the rage. Cars nearly killed me a dozen times and I was always more safe than the law required of me as a pedestrian. Most drivers don’t understand their power with today’s massive cars.

	▲	pandaman 2 hours ago \| parent [-]
		>Pulling into the bike lane for 30 seconds causes bikers to have to unsafely pull around the car Or, hear me out, they could stop if passing the car is unsafe.

▲

abeppu 4 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

> Waymos pull over into bike lanes all the time for pickups and drop-offs and that’s neither legal nor safe.

While perhaps drop-offs are often relatively quick (though perhaps more risky; see the dooring accident description in the article), I'm also really annoyed by Waymos waiting and blocking for pick-ups, which can be multiple minutes.

▲

scoofy 4 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I could give you dozens of examples of 30 seconds in a bike lane leading to cyclist life altering injuries and deaths.

▲

brendoelfrendo 4 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Cars pulling into cycling lanes injure and kill cyclists. Simple as.

▲

jMyles 2 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

> I want to hear how you equate "misery and death" with "unloading a passenger in the bike lane for 30 seconds".

I didn't say that.

I'm saying that the toll of traffic violence is unacceptable - tens of thousands of unanticipated and often gruesome fatalities, along with much larger numbers of injuries and traumatic experiences. So we look to autonomous vehicles to be better-behaved - particularly in terms of speed and attention, but also in the little things, like lawful/traditional engagement with lanes for smaller conveyances.

I'm an avid cyclist and I kinda hate bike lanes; I don't blame cars for not knowing how to treat them. I much prefer either a shared lane with a slow pace or a totally separated trail for bikes.

But at the end of the day, the standard for autonomous vehicles isn't parity with the negligence and aggression that cars currently foist upon society, it's much higher.

▲

skybrian 4 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

How do you know it’s “violent?” It might not technically be allowed but that doesn’t mean they’re doing it unsafely.

There’s quite a difference between violent and illegal and they shouldn’t be confused.

▲

vlovich123 4 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

A) I see no evidence this is creating death or misery. Autonomous still seems safer.

B) even if in this one aspect they remain status quo, overall it would still be an improvement.

▲

SpicyLemonZest 4 hours ago | parent [-]

The source article describes an incident where a cyclist was seriously injured after Waymo's cyclist detection system failed while it was parked in a bike lane, allowing the passenger to hit her with the door. I don't think this represents some terrible sin where Waymo executives should all go to prison, but I do think we can reasonably expect and if necessary demand that Waymo take action to prevent similar incidents in the future.

▲

jmalicki 4 hours ago | parent | next [-]

If the cyclist was doored by an exiting passenger, would t that imply it should further block the bike lane to increase safety as it is not safe for a bike to pass while a passenger is exiting? If the car door opening is what injuries the cyclist it wasn't really in the bike line very far.

▲

dylan604 4 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

> Waymo's cyclist detection system failed

I did a quick search on this, but was nothing but PR articles about how they lower cyclist/pedestrian collisions. Are you suggesting the Waymo car sees oncoming cyclists and somehow prevents the rider from opening the door? This would be interesting in how it could be done. Does it indicate in any way that the door will not be able to be opened until the cyclist clears, or is the rider left wondering why the damn car won't let them out?

	▲	reitzensteinm 4 hours ago \| parent \| next [-]
		From my experience, a tiny alarm sounds, a voice says cyclist approaching and the door clicks to locked. At least I believe it did, I heard a sound. I didn't check the handle. I don't believe the car was specifically in a bike lane at this time but I'm new to the city and may have missed the markings.
	▲	SpicyLemonZest 4 hours ago \| parent \| prev \| next [-]
		In general, Waymo keeps track of all nearby vehicles and pedestrians and shows them on the car's nav system. I've been in one before when it detected a cyclist coming from behind, and it gave clear warnings both audibly and visually, although I don't know whether it actually locked the door.
	▲	kotaKat 4 hours ago \| parent \| prev [-]
		It sees oncoming cyclists but only warns the passengers inside via visual cue on the displays and an audible cue through the speakers. Apparently external cues to the cyclist are also given that a door may open (blinking lights?)? https://waymo.com/community/articles/advocacy-meets-innovati...

▲

sigmar 4 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

>allowing the passenger to hit her with the door.

the bar is absurdly high if we're blaming the car manufacturer for mistakes human make after the car stops

▲

nandomrumber 4 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

Cars are violence now.

What next?