Remix.run Logo
Animats 2 days ago

1. In the essay version of the Turing test, an examiner decides which of two essays was written by a human and which by a machine. Convince the examiner that you are the human.

If the examiner is any good, they'll realize that's no longer possible.

2. Is body language a language?

Definitional question. The usual vocabulary is too small for a general purpose language.

3. Are dreams more like movies or video games?

Video games. You have some agency.

4. ‘Only animals who are below civilization and the angels who are beyond it can be sincere’ (W.H. AUDEN). Discuss.

The brighter animals can deceive. Ever been fooled by a crow? Can't speak to angels; never met one.

5. Should the UN pass a declaration of rights extending beyond humans?

No. They have enough problems.

6. Invent a new punctuation mark!

We have enough emoji already.

7. Is the contemporary art market a form of tulip fever?

No, it's a form of status signalling. A lek.

8. When did the beautiful become the good?

Some time before Plato.

9. Should Job Centres offer opportunities for sex work?

Absent coercion, yes.

10. Are all asylum seekers equal?

Some are more equal than others.

IshKebab 2 days ago | parent [-]

> they'll realize that's no longer possible

It definitely is. AI isn't perfect yet. It still has well-known flaws like the inability to count letters or say "I don't know". Definitely harder in the form of an essay than a conversation though. Especially because there's a decent chance someone has written "the answer" on the web somewhere and AI can just regurgitate it.

libraryofbabel a day ago | parent [-]

These are flaws from 6-12 months ago. You might want to spend some time talking to Opus 4.7 or GPT 5.5. I can assure you that they can count letters just fine.

You’re right that AI isn't perfect, but it’s pretty good. Especially since December last year which was an inflection point in capability.

IshKebab a day ago | parent [-]

Those don't seem to be available for free so I'll take your word for it on the letter counting. They still can't say "I don't know" though can they? I think it would still be pretty easy to weed out AI in a Turing test with a competent examiner and a human that wants to prove they are human.