| ▲ | tock 2 hours ago | ||||||||||||||||
They were scientific in spite of being religious. Not because of it. > that I don't think are matched by atheism at its best There are plenty of scientists including Feynman and Hawkings. These are unrelated things. | |||||||||||||||||
| ▲ | xyzelement 2 hours ago | parent [-] | ||||||||||||||||
>> They were scientific in spite of being religious. Not because of it. Can you justify that claim? >> plenty of scientists including Feynman and Hawkings. Feynman is a good example of that. He was raised in a religious family and went to synagogue every week. His dad challenged him to continuously challenge the orthodox knowledge which I suspect the father himself saw within the talmudic tradition etc. As feynman rejected Judaism and religion in general he nonetheless hung on and hugely benefited from the approach his religious father instilled on him. Similar to what I said about Einstein above I am not trying to claim feynman for religion but I think he's very far from "today's atheists" if that makes sense. If feynman didn't have his father (for whom religion was integral) I doubt he'd turn out who he was. >> These are unrelated things As per above I don't see it that way. | |||||||||||||||||
| |||||||||||||||||