I have internalised that in mathematics nice things come in bouquets. If there is a thing defined with properties A, B, C, and there is an other thing defined with properties D, E, F, then chances are that those 2 things are the same thing, because there are only so few nice concepts.

There are many types of examples, and many different reasons why I don't find a particular connection or connection type surprising. So I can concentrate on memorising them, and building intuition.

For the Fundamental Theorem of Calculus:

  - int f' = f: the sum of the change is the thing itself. E.g. pour water in the bathtub, if you sum the rate you pour, that's the total water in the bathtub
  - int f' = f(t2) - f(t1) : same but water differences between 2 times.
  - (int f)' = f: the rate of the sum is the function itself. If you go and integrate your function f, the integrate function's change rate at x is f(x) 
  - and so on. 

> the area under an entire curve being related to the derivative at only two points

This is a very wrong sentence. The area under f on [a,b] is not related to the derivative of f at a and b. The area under f on [0,x] is a real function F(x) by definition, and there is nothing surprising that the area of f on [a,b] is F(b)-F(a). Simple interval arithmetic. Granted F, the integral function, is related to f: F' = f.

tl;dr : in the "fundamental theorem of calculus" there are 2 main observations:

  - the operators 'sum of' and 'change rate' are each other's inverse and commute: 
  
       (int f)' = int (f') = f
                              
       F' = f  <==>  int f = F
  
  - from interval arithmetics:
  
       S(a,b) = S(0,b) - S(0,a)