In practice, it isn't. What you're identifying as potentially nightmarish - and no doubt quite tedious in git - are things that JJ enables you to do with a small subset of commands that work exactly how you expect them to work _in every workflow context_ in which they are needed.

Thinking specifically about conflicts: being able to defer conflicts until you're ready to deal with them is actually great. I might not be done with what I am actually working on and might want to finish that first. being forced into a possibly complicated conflict resolution when I'm in the middle of something is what I'd actually consider nightmarish.

When you want to solve the conflict: `jj new <rev>`, solve the conflict, then `jj squash`, your conflict resolution is automatically propagated to the chain of child commits from the conflict.