On the other hand, "are you sure you want to exit without saving" is a good use-case. But I'd prefer that to be a setting I can allow for specific site.

▲

gwbas1c 3 hours ago | parent | next [-]

That API has quite a few heuristics that protect the user:

(At least on the Chromium browsers that I've tested it with)

1: It fails silently if the user hasn't interacted with the page. (IE, the user needs to "do something" other than scroll, like click or type.) This generally stops most SPAM.

2: The browser detects loops / repeated prompting and has a checkbox to get out of the loop.

---

It was a little jarring the first time I used that API and tested my code with it; but I appreciate the protections. I've come across far too many "salesman putting their foot in the door" usage of it.

▲

wat10000 4 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

Better yet, just save. Storage is cheap and fast these days. The “do you want to save?” idiom is a leftover from the days when a moderately sized document would take a noticeable amount of time to save and eat up a decent chunk of your floppy disk.

▲

tripflag 4 hours ago | parent | next [-]

But what if you are leaving the page because you changed your mind, and don't wish to save the changes after all? This, for me, is the common case, so i would not want the browser to suddenly commit an unfinished draft.

	▲	wat10000 4 hours ago \| parent [-]
		If you’re worried about losing the old version, it should keep a history. If you want to erase the new version, there should be an explicit action to do that.

▲

Sayrus 3 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

An unfinished upload or sync stored locally instead of on the remote can absolutely be an issue. You can look at all the posts about OneDrive and GDrive not actually syncing before confirming to users who then delete their files since they "have been uploaded". Or the user may never open that specific page again or the session will not exist anymore when he comes back.

Browser storage is cheap, but it is not guaranteed to be durable.

	▲	wat10000 2 hours ago \| parent [-]
		That's a good point. You'd want some (overridable) way to block navigating away until the sync completed, or do it in the background. Local storage is pretty easy, remote can get tricky.