Isn't the whole signed request part a hard requirement for 3rd party access? S3 was originally designed for web use, which means giving not-fully-trusted browsers some access to your storage bucket.

You can't exactly do "this client is allowed to download this one specific file for the next 24 hours (but not use it like their personal CDN and share the link with everyone)" or "this client is allowed to upload a single image file up to 10MB (but not upload a 100GB copy of Friends)" with basic bearer tokens.

Of course you can do all that with a basic bearer token. It’s just a signed json object with an expiration