Remix.run Logo
hungryhobbit 3 hours ago

I categorically reject that assertion. Two simple examples: 1) when you see someone assaulting someone else, it's absolutely ok to attack them, and 2) the American revolution!

It's like that old joke:

A man offers a young woman $1,000,000 to sleep with him for one night.

“For a million dollars? Sure, I’ll sleep with you.”

He smiles at her, “How about $50, then?”

“How dare you! I’m not a whore!”

“Look, lady, we’ve already agreed what you are, now we’re just negotiating the price.”

Similarly in this case, you can't make up absolutes and assert the're true, while ignoring that the real world is more complicated. And once you do realize the world is complicated, you realize there aren't absolutes: everyone is a prostitute, terrorist, or whatever other bad label you want to throw at them ... it's just a matter of degree.

So no, it's not always wrong to physically attack someone like this. You can debate specifically whether Altman has committed enough violence himself to justify violence against him: that's something two people can reasonably disagree on. But you can't just say "violence bad" like its some great pearl of wisdom, while ignoring that violence has in fact been good many times throughout history.

3 hours ago | parent | next [-]
[deleted]
etchalon 3 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

It's always OK to punch a Nazi.

gagagagaga an hour ago | parent | next [-]

the left really eased up on nazi name-calling when they all became obsessed with the jews

suby 2 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

One problem with that thought process is that the label nazi gets thrown around and misused to the point where it becomes meaningless. I've seen threads on tech forums like lobste.rs where prominent people in the industry like DHH are called nazi's. We should recognize that labels are often coupled with hyperbole. We should not be advocating for violence.

angoragoats 33 minutes ago | parent | next [-]

DHH has expressed clear public support for white nationalist causes and figures, on multiple occasions. What else should we call him?

bdangubic an hour ago | parent | prev [-]

you should read up on DHH and then perhaps pick another example

Jerrrrrrrry 2 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

[dead]