Remix.run Logo
delis-thumbs-7e 4 hours ago

I’m studying currently Phenomenology of Geist. No code is so gard to read as it.

dugidugout 31 minutes ago | parent | next [-]

Blah I need to get around to this!

I often gesture towards this phenomenology when religious folk casually attempt to claim "spirit" as some form of belief they hold over me. I honestly don't know if I've developed the position well, it is almost entirely through the lens of continental philosophy absorbing Hegel, but I use it to illustrate that my concept of spirit, as an atheist, may not be a different phenomenological occurrence than that of a religious framing and even shares the quality of a rich historical lineage I can draw from. I could just as easily retreat into untranslated German that sounds poetic or prophetic to the uninitiated, but that would be doing exactly what I'm asking them not to do, leaning on a vocabulary the other person can't engage with without first conceding the ground it's built on. This seems to effectively persuade them to adjust their vocabulary to a register I can actually engage with without needing to hedge for the axiomatic differences we have.

This is a comfortable mode of engagement and it is one I can share with religious folk, but I do find they often refuse this register and I will admit I can't always articulate why I find their refusal frustrating either.

mykowebhn 4 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Did you start with the Preface, or are you going to read it at the end?

(I strongly recommend the latter.)

efficax 4 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

Just wait until you get into the Science of Logic

sigbottle 4 hours ago | parent [-]

I'm starting with the Science of Logic!

I want to cry...

mykowebhn 4 hours ago | parent [-]

The first part of his Encyclopedia will help a lot, and might be better to read first before diving into SoL.