new | show | ask | jobs Github

afshinmeh 4 hours ago

That's correct. The pattern is: reads allowed, write and network I/O blocked by default.

```

zerobox -- curl https://example.com

Could not resolve host: example.com

```

▲ simonw 3 hours ago | parent [-]

Oh so it allows ALL file reads?

I'd feel safer with default-deny on reads as well, but I know from past experience that this gets tricky fast - tools like Node.js and uv and Python all have a bunch of files they need to be able to read that you might not predict in advance.

Might still be possible to do that in a DX-friendly way though, if you make it easy to manually approve reads the first time and use that to build a profile that can be reused on subsequent command invocations.

▲ afshinmeh 3 hours ago | parent [-]

I agree and you can deny all reads like this:

```

zerobox --deny-read=/ -- cat /etc/passwd

```

That being said, what the default DX shouldl be? What paths to deny by default? That's something I've been thinking about and I'd love to hear your thoughts.

▲ simonw 3 hours ago | parent [-]

That's a really tough question. I always worry about credentials that are tucked away in ~/.folders in my home directory like in ~/.aws - but you HAVE to provide access to some of those like ~/.claude because otherwise Claude Code won't work.

That's why rather than a default set I'm interested in an option where I get to approve things on first run - maybe something like this:

  zerobox --build-profile claude-profile.txt -- claude

The above command would create an empty claude-profile.txt file and then give me a bunch of interactive prompts every time Claude tried to access a file, maybe something like:

  claude wants to read ~/.claude/config.txt
  A) allow that file, D) allow full ~/.claude directory, X) exit

You would then clatter through a bunch of those the first time you run Claude and your decisions would be written to claude-profile.txt - then once that file exists you can start Claude in the future like this:

  zerobox --profile claude-profile.txt -- claude

(This is literally the first design I came up with after 30s of thought, I'm certain you could do much better.)

▲

afshinmeh 3 hours ago | parent [-]

Fantastic! I like that idea. I'm also exploring an option to define profiles, but also have predefines profiles that ships with the binary (e.g. Claude, then block all `.env` reads, etc.)

▲

simonw 3 hours ago | parent [-]

Being able to mix and match profiles would be neat.

	▲	afshinmeh 3 hours ago \| parent [-]
		Give me 2 days :)