> I do some times wonder if any hiring managers see a lot of LinkedIn social post activity as a positive thing.

About a year ago I had a friend recommend me to their management. After three rounds of interviews, the CEO overrode the process and rejected me because I didn't have enough on my LinkedIn profile.

As far as I'm concerned, I dodged a bullet. If the CEO cares so much about LinkedIn filler that he'd overrule the hiring process, I'm certain I would have hated every moment working there.

▲

a4isms 4 hours ago | parent | next [-]

Hiring can remain irrational longer than you can remain unemployed.

One manager no-hires you because you don't post enough. Another doesn't like what you post. A third thinks you post too much. A fourth is pleased you seem to pay more attention to shipping products than hot takes. A fifth loves your hot takes.

So you get a call and are asked to do a coding thing. One person no-hires you because you wrote fizz-buzz by hand and didn't use Claude. Another wants to see that you know how to code by hand, but although your solution is fast, compact, and correct, it isn't the solution they had in mind.

At the end of the day, it's a highly inefficient, mostly irrational process dominated by social factors rather than objective feature detection.

▲

drfloyd51 4 hours ago | parent [-]

Agreed.

Even if we could quantize someone into a feature matrix, every hiring process demands unique matrixes.

Even if I pass all the quantifiable stuff… the first answer to an HR “off limits” question will be given soon enough if I get the job.

Turns out being a Jesus nerd was a secret requirement.

Wish they could just put that in the job requirements.

	▲	zugi 4 hours ago \| parent [-]
		> Turns out being a Jesus nerd was a secret requirement. Wish they could just put that in the job requirements. Title 7 of the Civil Rights Act, in making religious hiring discrimination illegal, sometimes just drives it underground. Over the years it's done more good than harm, but at a certain point it may be time to let those who want to hire only Jesus nerds self-select.

▲

MrDarcy 5 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

I have consulted for CEO’s and other executives who think like this. You certainly dodged a bullet.