Remix.run Logo
colechristensen 19 hours ago

The same logic can be used the opposite way, you can, with large amounts of money, manipulate events or people's responses to them.

* you can place large bets on events you have influence on the outcome for and make large amounts of money

* you can place large bets on events and then threaten people who have influence with a big stick

* you can place large bets expecting to lose money in order to change the outcome or a related outcome expecting people to look at the odds and change their behavior

And probably lots of other ways.

It corrupts events and on a world stage with unethical government in vogue... it's not impossible for people to manipulate a war in order to make bets go their way.

Lerc 19 hours ago | parent [-]

There was recently a story about a reporter who faced threats because their reporting contained a detail that while not significantly impactful (although about a literal impact) in it's own right changed the win conditions on a prediction bet.

I think prediction markets worked as an idea to provide a wisdom of the crowd view when they were being used in good faith, but rewards cause people to prioritise winning and gaming the system pays better than playing fairly.

phil21 13 hours ago | parent [-]

There is no unfairly or fairly playing a prediction market. That's kind of the point. They don't work if you try to regulate them like they are a stock market or sports betting market. If you place money on one as a layman, you should consider yourself the dumb money. Lots of folks have convinced themselves they "know better" though, so it's a very easy psychological sell.

You either allow a free for all, or they should be simply outright banned. I mean, they should probably be banned either way - but without the prediction part this is not a single redeeming factor for them to exist.

The consequences for someone betting on classified information would need to come from the agency/government/etc. that finds out their staff is engaging in betting on privileged information. The market itself is simply taking bets and doing what it's designed to do. The bettor gets to decide if the risk is worth it.