Remix.run Logo
crote 4 hours ago

Seconding the use of p4merge for easy-to-use three-pane merging. Just like most other issues with Git, if your merges are painful it's probably due to terrible native UX design - not due to anything conceptually wrong with Git.

roryokane 3 hours ago | parent | next [-]

Did you know that VS Code added support for the same four-pane view as p4merge years ago? I used p4merge as my merge tool for a long time, but I switched to VS Code when I discovered that, as VS Code’s syntax highlighting and text editing features are much better than p4merge’s.

I also use the merge tool of JetBrains IDEs such as IntelliJ IDEA (https://www.jetbrains.com/help/idea/resolve-conflicts.html#r...) when working in those IDEs. It uses a three-pane view, not a four-pane view, but there is a menu that allows you to easily open a comparison between any two of the four versions of the file in a new window, so I find it similarly efficient.

TacticalCoder 4 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

Thirding it except I do it from Emacs. Three side-by-side pane with left / common ancestor / right and then below the merge result. By default it's not like that but then it's Emacs so anything is doable. I hacked some elisp code a great many years ago and I've been using it ever since.

No matter the tool, merges should always be presented like that. It's the only presentation that makes sense.

MarsIronPI 4 hours ago | parent | next [-]

What tool do you use? Does Magit support it natively?

skydhash 4 hours ago | parent [-]

I think you need to enable 3 way merge by default in git's configuration, and both smerge (minor mode for solving conflicts) and ediff (major mode that encompass diff and patch) will pick it up. In the case of the latter you will have 4 panes, one for version A, another for version B, a third for the result C, and the last is the common ancestor of A and B.

Addendum: I've since long disabled it. A and B changes are enough for me, especially as I rebase instead of merging.

jwr 4 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

Isn't that what ediff does?