Sorry, I thought my edit was fast enough.

Yes it did hit HN and you just said, "I stand by what I wrote." and then complain about buggy implementations and downtime connected to DNSSEC. As if that isn't true for all technologies, let alone /insecure/ DNS. DNS is connected to a lot of downtime because it undergirds the whole internet. Making the distributed database that delegates domain authority cryptographically secure makes everything above it more secure too.

I rebutted your arguments point-by-point. You don't update your blog post to reflect those arguments nor recent developments, like larger key sizes.

▲

tptacek 7 hours ago | parent [-]

Did you write the article?

▲

indolering 6 hours ago | parent [-]

Yup.

▲

tptacek 6 hours ago | parent [-]

So: I wrote a blog post in January of 2015, and 7 months later you wrote a blog post responding to it in August of 2015, and 10 years later you're still angry that I didn't update my blog post to point to the post that you wrote?

I write things people disagree with all the time. I can't recall ever having been mad that people didn't cite me for things we disagree about. Should I have expected all the people who hated coding agents to update their articles when I wrote "My AI Skeptic Friends Are All Nuts"? I didn't realize I was supposed to be complaining about that.

▲

indolering 5 hours ago | parent [-]

I advocate for DNSSEC in my personal life and you happen to jump on every DNSSEC HN submission and repeat your claims. So I post a link to my article debunking them. You won't engage in the substantive points here but insist that you have in the past and that you stand by your post. So I suggest your update your post to address my critiques.

I'm frustrated that you seem to blow me off and insult me when I try to engage in good faith discussion, but I'm not angry at you. I just ran into this post while procrastinating at work and here we are, in the same loop.

I think we are both trying to make the internet a safer place. It's sad we can't seem to have a productive conversation on the matter.

	▲	tptacek 5 hours ago \| parent [-]
		I advocate against DNSSEC in my personal life. I write about DNSSEC on HN because I write on HN a lot, and because this is a topic I have invested a lot of time in, going back long before the existence of HN itself. You can find stuff about it from me on NANOG in the 1990s. Your frustration seems like a "you" problem.