> The anticheat is to stop 1 guy from ruining it for the 9 others he's playing with online.

Don't play with untrusted randoms. Play with people you know and trust. That's the true solution.

That is not the solution if you want to play competitively of whenever you feel like it.

Kernel level AC is a compromise for sure and it's the gamers job to assess if the game is worth the privacy risk but I'd say it's much more their right to take that risk than the cheaters right to ruin 9 other people's time for their own selfish amusement

▲

matheusmoreira 7 hours ago | parent [-]

Cheating may not be moral but it's better to put up with it than to cede control of our computers to the corporations that want to own it.

If it kills online gaming, then so be it. I accept that sacrifice. The alternative leads to the destruction of everything the word hacker ever stood for.

▲

jack_pp 7 hours ago | parent [-]

I'm sorry but you are fighting a crusade you can not win by definition. If I am free to use my computer for anything I want then I am also free to lock it down to enjoy my favorite game. If I care about my freedom I will have a dedicated machine for this game that I accept I will not have control over.

You are hijacking this thread about VOLUNTARY ceasing of freedom as if the small community even willing to install these is a slippery slope to something worse. You have a point when it comes to banking apps on rooted phones and I'm with you on that but this is not the thread for it

▲

matheusmoreira 5 hours ago | parent [-]

Valve drives significant development of compatibility layers for Linux for the sake of gaming. Their customer base is anything but small. There is potential for this kernel stuff to spill into the entire Linux ecosystem. It was bad enough having to deal with nvidia. I really don't want other companies screwing up the kernel.

▲

jack_pp 4 hours ago | parent [-]

again fighting against windmills, valve isn't even mentioned in the article. Valve's anti-cheat for CS2 is user-mode.

Do you have evidence valve is working to infect the linux kernel for everyone?

▲

int_19h 4 hours ago | parent | next [-]

Realistically I don't see how Valve can avoid this. They want all those games on Steam Deck and the new console. Game devs want KAC. Therefore Valve can either provide them with some way to implement KAC - which effectively requires a "signed kernel / drivers only", same as on Windows - or tell them to go away. Why would they do the latter?

Mind you, it doesn't mean that the Linux kernel will be "infected for everyone". It means that we'll see the desktop Linux ecosystem forking into the "secure" Linux which you don't actually have full control of but which you need to run any app that demands a "secure" environment (it'll start with KAC but inevitably progress to other kinds of DRM such as video streaming etc). Or you can run Linux that you actually control, but then you're missing on all those things. Similar to the current situation with mainline Android and its user-empowering forks.

	▲	matheusmoreira 6 minutes ago \| parent \| next [-]
		> we'll see the desktop Linux ecosystem forking into the "secure" Linux > Or you can run Linux that you actually control, but then you're missing on all those things We cannot allow this stuff to be normalized. We can't just sit by and allow ourselves to be discriminated against for the crime of owning our own devices. We should be able to have control and have all of those nice things. Everything is gonna demand "secure" Linux. Banks want it because fraud. Copyright monopolists want it because copyright infringement. Messaging services want it because bots. Government wants it because encryption. At some point they might start demanding attestation to connect to the fucking internet. If this stuff becomes normal it's over. They win. I can't be the only person who cares about this stuff.
	▲	jack_pp 4 hours ago \| parent \| prev [-]
		Streaming services already have a solution for environments where they can't run DRM - crap quality stream. My solution to their solution? torrents. People can dual boot, what's wrong with a special gaming linux distribution?

▲

matheusmoreira 34 minutes ago | parent | prev [-]

From what I've read they actually tried to push back against it. I'm just saying this stuff is coming to our systems and should be resisted.

▲

whs 6 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I wish that is an option. Nowadays many non competitives games that you play with friends you trust still use EAC (yet accept non-kernel mode operation on Linux). I suppose other than VAC you can't buy a usermode anticheat middleware now.

▲

babypuncher 7 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

I'm starting to think you've never actually played an online game before