My example was not great.

But my point is that I read HN partly because people here are insightful in a way I can't get in other places. If LLMs turn out to ultimately be just as insightful, then my incentive to read HN is reduced to just, "read what other people like me are thinking." That's not nothing, but I can get that by just talking with my friends.

Unless, of course, we could get human+LLM insightfulness in HN and then I'd get the best of both worlds.