Remix.run Logo
ralferoo a day ago

True | False | FileNotFound was a meme about 2 decades ago, and even that was a reference to MSDOS from another 2 decades earlier. I guess things never change, only the language.

Even now, I still find myself using true/false/null on occasions, but I'm usually smart enough to replace it with an enum at that point. The only time I don't is when it's an optional parameter to a function to override some default/existing value, at which point it then makes sense to keep it as an optional bool.

hinkley a day ago | parent | next [-]

I did a govt contract early on and learned that yes/no/unanswered/unasked was a common quad. I see that in disclosures when applying for jobs as well.

gizmo686 a day ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I'm surprised that trinary logic has not become a standard part of standard libraries yet. Almost every project I have worked on ends up with some form of a yes/no/maybe abstraction.

hinkley a day ago | parent | next [-]

With privacy coming back into vogue, it’s useful to distinguish “we didn’t ask” from “they wouldn’t answer”

For some vector logic the distinction could matter.

Aurornis a day ago | parent | prev [-]

Yes/No/Maybe is a good fit for an enum because “Maybe” carries some specific information.

For more common situations where the yes/no bool is not available yet or should not be considered, constructs like Rust’s Option<bool> are a very good fit. Layering the bool inside of an Option creates intentional handling about the presence or lack of value first before you can work with it.

nine_k 18 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

This just means that the problem requires more than a Boolean, but rather something like boolean | error. In many languages from the OOP heyday that alternative part was expressed via throwing an exception.