Remix.run Logo
giantg2 3 hours ago

So if it's established as unconstitutional, couldn't you file a criminal complaint of official oppression against the members of whatever government approved the cameras since they are levying unconstitutional fines?

jcranmer 2 hours ago | parent | next [-]

As an individual and not the government, you can't file a criminal action.

You could file a civil action for violation of constitutional rights, but under Roberts, SCOTUS has basically been ripping out all of the mechanisms that would let you file such suits.

giantg2 2 hours ago | parent [-]

"As an individual and not the government, you can't file a criminal action."

You can file with the police, if they take it. You can also file as a private criminal complaint in many jurisdictions. However, it's up to the DA to approve it most of the time. There can be an appeal process where a judge would make a determination.

But yes, if the whole system is corrupt, then there's not much to do.

empressplay 2 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

If they invalidate every contested fine nobody has any standing to make a legal complaint.

giantg2 an hour ago | parent [-]

They're only invalidating it if you fight it. The people who paid it and later realized it was unconstitutional may have standing.