Remix.run Logo
throwaw12 5 hours ago

This doesn't include generational damage in sentiment:

* Europe is in trouble because they can't get gas from Russia, Qatar stopped supplying gas

* Japan is in trouble because Middle East supplies its 75% of oil, which is blocked now

* Ukraine is in dilemma, because US giving every support to Israel, but not to Ukraine

* Qatar, Kuwait, UAE, Bahrain is asking questions, if US can't defend us and is moving all defensive missiles to protect Israel, why should we even be ally with them in the future, they're scared even more (except UAE) that people might overthrow those kings if things continue this way

* Africa understood its better to work with China, than with US

roysting 3 hours ago | parent | next [-]

That’s just the tip of the iceberg. People here seem to also have no perspective, since it is not in the wheelhouse of most tech people, on the fact that this is all a part of a 40 year strategy (as Netanyahu himself has openly stated) that some refer to as the “the Clean Break Strategy” or the “7 countries in 5 years memo”[1]. It clearly took longer than 5 years, but they definitely tried and even the likes of Hillary “we came, we saw, he died” Clinton was a party of that.

People always squabble over blue team vs red team, never realizing that the whole game is just a ruse to provide a sense of democratic control to placate the public, and also give the apparatchiks if the regime a sense of autonomy, when in fact they’re just all pulling at the same continuity of agenda like beasts of burden, being whipped and rode by a very small group that hold their reins.

[1] https://x.com/wikileaks/status/1819709215352438921?lang=en

ajross 2 hours ago | parent [-]

Counterargument: squabbling about "blue team vs red team" is legitimate domestic politics about issues important to voters. You're just upset because what you think the "the whole game" is about is a rare area of general agreement[1] and you happen to be on the "other side".

To wit: when you disagree with everyone, it looks like they're conspiring against you to control the masses, yada yada yada. They're not, you're just in a small minority (or an epistemological prison).

[1] Hardly surprising, since international geopolitics is exactly where you'd expect their interests to align.

gravisultra 10 minutes ago | parent | next [-]

How my tax dollars are spent is a domestic issue. As is not implicating me in war crimes.

> They're not, you're just in a small minority

The majority do not support this war, nor do they support Israel. Our politicians refusing to listen to the electorate is also a domestic issue. As are the many attempts that Israel has made to strip us of our fundamental rights.

throwaw12 an hour ago | parent | prev [-]

red team was against endless wars in Middle East, red team specifically elected Trump to be America first and to stop all wars.

if it was indeed about domestic policies, why promises were not held given to the "team"?

ajross an hour ago | parent [-]

Sorry, no. The republican party of the last three-quarter-century has been consistently and reliably pro-American-exceptionalism. That the republican power structures backed a candidate who claimed not to believe these things is interesting, but it happened because they believed, CORRECTLY, that he was lying about this.[1]

There has been no significant realignment of US geopolitical positioning between the parties, nor should you expect there to have been. That you thought there was is, to be blunt, on you. You followed a charlatan and got burned. You should have known better after you got burned the first time.

[1] Again, hardly surprising. He lies about everything.

jklinger410 4 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I think citizens in those countries recognize that allowing a repressive regime to exist simply for cheap oil costs is not necessarily a good solution, either.

throwaw12 4 hours ago | parent | next [-]

until your energy bills impact your pocket directly, while you were laid off from your manufacturing plant, because their cost structure is not competitive without cheap Russian oil/gas

Look at the correlation here starting from 2022: https://cepr.org/voxeu/columns/recent-weakness-german-manufa...

roncesvalles 3 hours ago | parent [-]

This is akin to someone in 1861 saying US cotton plantations, and by extension the entire Southern economy, aren't viable without slavery, so let's allow slavery to run.

Western liberal civilization has theta decay without occasional violent intervention.

Imagine if we didn't go all-out against communism.

philistine 32 minutes ago | parent | next [-]

The West didn't go all out at all against communism. Europe barely spent anything, and the US spent pennies on the dollar. The communists were bankrupt trying to keep up with the collective West spending loose change on military and intrigue.

throwaw12 3 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

By the way, I am not saying we should exploit people, I am just saying majority of people don't care about what they are not seeing face to face or feeling face to face, majority people care about direct impact on their pockets and lifestyle.

keybored 2 hours ago | parent [-]

People can speak for themselves.

throwaw12 3 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

> ... so let's allow slavery to run.

Obviously we look at world differently, but I was under impression that slavery wasn't abolished, it just got different form with slightly more rights.

Late-Capitalism as slave owners, workers as slaves, because their health insurance tied to their work, they can be punished without notice (at will employment), wealth gap is 50-2000x between Lord in feudalism (CEO / rich / ultrarich) and slaves. Lord can rape (Epstein class), avoid taxes, bribe each other, the moment slave does the same, goes to jail for 10 years

Same nature, different form, more modern form

khazhoux 2 hours ago | parent [-]

No offense intended, but that is an ignorant take. The law of the land in the U.S. was that one human could literally own another human being (with all the implications of property ownership, including disposing of it and abusing it at your leisure). How such a despicable mindset took hold and was allowed to go on for so long, is beyond modern comprehension.

You mentioned many other injustices but none of those are "slavery but just different with slightly more rights."

throwaw12 an hour ago | parent [-]

you are just describing the shades of grey, even if one looks brighter, doesn't change the fact that it is still grey, I think your take is too simplistic.

Human nature didn't change, it is still power hungry, small percentage of narcissistic people want to control the masses and exploit, give them a chance (I mean to current capitalists), you will become a slave.

Look at the Elon and what he did to X employees, some were sleeping in the office "proudly", who still got laid off anyways, look at the Bezos, who fought against forming unions. So you think those people are different then slave owners? deep inside they are same, power and capital hungry, ready to do anything to get more powerful (see any big tech corporate, blood bath of politics at the top to fight for staffing and stack ranking to show "impact")

lukan 3 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Because they all live themself in repressive regimes?

qingcharles 2 hours ago | parent [-]

If you're talking about the Qataris, Kuwaitis and Bahrainis, they generally don't consider themselves[1] repressed, even though it looks that way from say an American perspective. (Women's rights are definitely a huge issue still) Those countries are very quickly becoming enormously Westernized, though. Just don't ask how many women politicians there are.

[1] only speaking of the natives, immigrants of all flavors have a very different situation

lukan an hour ago | parent [-]

If you ask iranians, it also strongly depends who you ask, whether they confirm or debate the claim that they are repressed.

megous 3 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

No, we realize US americans elected gerontoidiot Trump, and we constnantly ask ourselves what the actual fuck after every third act of this senile imbecile. Do you not have young (like at least < 60) people who can still actually think critically, have strategy, hold ideas for more than 30 seconds. Are you impressed by senility? Why do you support someone who attacks european countries frequently just on the basis of whimsy shit like not wanting to go with you into wars of aggression agaisnt third countries, like you attacked Spain most recently? What the actual fuck?

That people think in terms of good/vs/evil and that US will somehow come out of this as a liked country that did good is beyond me. The constant attempts at painting some morals or grand strategy over the constant random unhinged acts of senile imbecile that gets bootlicked by everyone around him just comes out as insane.

That's what at least this european thinks of US, yeah. :)

Unhinged country with unhinged lunatic at the top, all this is. That's what americans should be thinking hard about, not about another new ways to rationalize his insanity and insane criminal acts.

mkoubaa 3 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

[flagged]

jklinger410 2 hours ago | parent [-]

Oppression is a spectrum. I wouldn't compare "taxes" to something like, I don't know, killing gay people and forcing women to cover their bodies and hair.

mkoubaa 2 hours ago | parent [-]

Taxation is slavery

kakacik 4 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

Almost nobody thinks like that, what are we 5 year olds? Especially when most left leaning folks in western world has hard sympathies with hamas which are just left and right hand of the same regime (maybe not US left which is far from left elsewhere).

Did US population en masse lost sleep during past decades till now and some future due to sweatshops full of kids making their jeans or iphones or Christmas toys for their kids in highly undemocratic regimes?

jklinger410 2 hours ago | parent [-]

> Especially when most left leaning folks in western world has hard sympathies with hamas

I'm not going to take your comment seriously due to this wild opinion.

underdeserver 3 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

> Qatar, Kuwait, UAE, Bahrain is asking questions, if US can't defend us and is moving all defensive missiles to protect Israel, why should we even be ally with them

Where are you getting this information? The UAE, for instance, is relying heavily on missile defense - and it's working out for them:

https://gulfnews.com/uae/uae-intercepts-186-ballistic-missil...

It's all US technology, too:

https://www.wired.me/story/inside-the-system-that-intercepte...

lm28469 3 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

> Europe is in trouble because they can't get gas from Russia, Qatar stopped supplying gas

60% of it comes from the US, a lot from northern Africa too, not much comes from the middle east

karmakurtisaani 3 hours ago | parent [-]

The price of oil has skyrocketed because of the dumbfuck war. Doesn't matter where the oil comes when it costs too much and causes massive inflation once again.

flyinglizard 4 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

The disruption in gas supply will be very short. Weeks, at most. The gulf states will be very happy to see the Islamic Republic gone, they are living in its shadow for a long time now. Now, Ukraine and Israel need very different kinds of support, and things like US withholding intelligence from Ukraine have nothing to do with Israel.

hedora 4 hours ago | parent | next [-]

Iran has been bombing production facilities across a bunch of US allies. It's unclear how quickly those will be rebuilt. Also, the US is probably bombing Iranian production, which means countries like China will be looking for additional sources.

karmakurtisaani 2 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

> The disruption in gas supply will be very short.

Remember when W declared mission accomplished? That war was so short too.

> The gulf states will be very happy to see the Islamic Republic gone

Would they be happy to see a devastating civil war that gives rise to a successor of ISIS or Taleban? Will they happily accept tens of millions of refugees?

Absolutely nothing good will come from this dumbfuck war. We all will pay the price of it one way or another.

throwaw12 4 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

I wonder why Israel should get any support, do you support killing children and bombing schools?

Ukraine, I understand, because it was attacked, but Israel, who was oppressing people for so many years with prisons full with Palestinian kids and teenagers long before Oct 7th, I really don't understand.

Except, for Epstein reasons (blackmail), other than that, there is no reason US should support Israel, in any way

dttze 4 hours ago | parent | next [-]

[dead]

flyinglizard 4 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

Israel should get support because supporting Israel right to exist, for me, is the right thing, and because its strategic goals and values align with those of the US.

throwaw12 4 hours ago | parent | next [-]

> supporting Israel right to exist, for me, is the right thing

1. Does US fight to support only right things?

2. Is Palestinian right to exist is the right thing as well?

readitalready 3 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

There is no moral justification for Israel's right to exist. Israel does not have a right to exist. They exist purely as a foreign invasion force originally started by European Jews - who didn't even practice or believe in Judaism - in order to make their own private racist mediterranean resort state by killing the native people and stealing their land.

What makes you think anyone would want support their existence over the rights of the existing Palestinian people that lived there and are currently fighting to reclaim their homes?

Religions do not have a right of inheritance. A person can't claim your home when you die because they also happen to be Christian. The only legal inheritance are those with title. And no one from Europe that decided to attack and invade Palestine can show any deed or title to the land they claimed to "own" 2000 years ago when they decided to move to Europe.

So, no. The state of Israel exists purely as a criminal enterprise of murder and theft. Let's not encourage its continued existence.

antonkochubey 3 hours ago | parent | next [-]

I wonder if perhaps something has happened to European Jews in the 1930s that made them look for a place to re-settle

throwaw12 3 hours ago | parent | next [-]

> made them look for a place to re-settle

re-settle is fine, Palestinians and Jews were living together in those areas for thousands of years.

Massacre, oppression and take over is not, especially when the problem wasn't caused by people living in those areas: Palestinians and Jews.

If anyone owes a land to European Jews, it is a Germany.

keybored 2 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

Zionism started long before Nazi Germany.

lukan 3 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

You do realize most Israelis were born there? Having a right to live where you are born is a pretty fundamental one.

throwaw12 2 hours ago | parent | next [-]

> You do realize most Israelis were born there?

So do Palestinians. It wasn't an empty land, right?

> Having a right to live where you are born is a pretty fundamental one.

I don't think West Bank settlers agree with you on this

lukan 2 hours ago | parent [-]

"I don't think West Bank settlers agree with you on this"

So? Did I said something that makes you think I agree with them on many points? There ain't just 2 extreme sides in this conflict.

bdangubic 3 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

President Trump would hard disagree with you on that one

lukan 3 hours ago | parent [-]

Fortunately he is not undisputed king of america, yet.

readitalready 2 hours ago | parent [-]

lol the Israelis would also disagree, otherwise they would have let the Palestinians live with them instead of literally going village-to-village, and door-to-door to forcibly remove the Palestinian residents or be killed if they didn't.

If the state of Israel doesn't believe in native rights, then you shouldn't believe in supporting their native rights either.

lukan 2 hours ago | parent [-]

Thank you, but I choose for myself what rights I support and yes, it is rights on both sides.

readitalready 2 hours ago | parent [-]

No... thank YOU for believing in the right of Palestinians to return to their homes.

lukan 2 hours ago | parent [-]

Oh, I do. Do you believe in the right of the Israelis to stay safe in their houses?

throwaw12 an hour ago | parent [-]

> Do you believe in the right of the Israelis to stay safe in their houses?

Yes, only if you clarify which house you mean, because some of them think Palestinian houses are theirs, Lebanon is theirs, Jordan is theirs, parts of Saudi Arabia is theirs, parts of Egypt is theirs.

lukan an hour ago | parent [-]

Houses they build or bought from the owner. But in general the situation surely is messy.

chmod775 4 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

> values align with those of the US

Some values those are. Yikes.

flyinglizard 3 hours ago | parent [-]

More chances than not that you live in a country that benefitted from the American propensity to do the right thing, even at a huge cost to itself. Yes we have a different and more selfish America now, but all said, America still protects the world order that allows this conversation to exist.

throwaw12 3 hours ago | parent [-]

we don't need good boys, we need good laws where everyone is equal and punished equally for violating the common moral principles, e.g. for being a pedophile