Remix.run Logo
qsera 5 hours ago

>It is impossible to accurately imitate the action of intelligent beings without being intelligent.

Wait what? So a robot who is accurately copying the actions of an intelligent human, is intelligent?

UltraSane 2 hours ago | parent | next [-]

How can you distinguish intelligence form a sufficiently accurate imitation of intelligence?

slopinthebag an hour ago | parent [-]

By "sufficiently accurate" do you mean identical? Because if so, it's not an imitation of intelligence at all, and the question is thus nonsensical.

UltraSane an hour ago | parent [-]

"it's not an imitation of intelligence at all"

But that is the key insight, how can you tell when an imitation of intelligence becomes the real thing?

empath75 4 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

That was probably phrased poorly. If a robot can independently accurately do what an intelligent person would do when placed in a novel situation, then yes, I would say it is intelligent.

If it's just basically being a puppet, then no. You tell me what claude code is more like, a puppet, or a person?