which has been warped all out of any comprehensible reality. It hinges on the idea of 'voluntarily' turning over information. Much of what is now considered information voluntarily turned over isn't even information that people know exist much less that they are turning over much less doing so voluntarily.

It's not voluntary if you don't know about it.

Requiring someone pay for information by any common sense interpretation isn't voluntary.

The courts have lost their goddamn minds.