Remix.run Logo
3eb7988a1663 4 hours ago

Is Microsoft ever going to implement proper VS Code plugin sandboxing? There are so many good extensions I would like to use, but I hate the security implications of loading yet more unvetted code for a nice-to-have.

Then again, I see that the top buzz in the industry is about Claws and letting LLMs run loose with only a handshake agreement to be safe, and I already know the answer.

StrangeSound an hour ago | parent | next [-]

And it's only getting worse with the waves of vibe-coders.

I actually wrote about this recently after poking around a popular extension that Antigravity users were installing. It's wild what people are doing with your credentials, and you'd have no idea! https://opista.com/posts/blind-trust-in-vs-code-extensions

dawnerd 34 minutes ago | parent [-]

I got in an argument with someone the other day that said their vibe coded app was more secure than something hand written because the ai “knows all exploits”.

We’re cooked.

christoph-heiss 25 minutes ago | parent [-]

That's why any repo with a README ridden with emojis (and other telltale signs) is just an instant nope nowadays.

(One of the only good things about GH is, that if you block some account, it will tell you if that account contributed to some repo at the top. Makes it very easy to filter out slopcode.)

MantisShrimp90 4 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

The only real answer is something like web assembly and that would be a major breaking change for them.

This is why allot run dev containers but agreed this really should be top priority but instead is probably in the "maybe if we have a major security incident" bucket of concerns as these things often are

frehu 4 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

There's no malware in it currently, but I understand your concerns - I could be lying, go rogue later, or just get my access stolen.

One option is to vet a version yourself and disable auto-update, but that's not really feasible to spend time on for most people.

3eb7988a1663 4 hours ago | parent [-]

Sorry, no sleight intended against you, just a general concern as more and more cool utilities keep getting built into the platform.

frehu 4 hours ago | parent [-]

No offense taken, you actually made me reconsider trying out random extensions that sound like mine to make sure i'm not reinventing the wheel

benatkin 4 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Doesn't seem like it. It will be stuck in a security theater situation, just like Chrome extensions. Not an upgrade from the old highly powerful firefox extensions or those of the Atom text editor.

frehu 4 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

[dead]