My argument is that we are getting closer, not that we know exactly what AGI will be. That is clearly part of it right? If we had some boolean definition I suspect we would already be there. Figuring it out is a big part of getting there. I think my points still stand based on this. We aren't there yet but it is hard to deny that these things are growing from a complexity/capability standpoint. On a spectrum from rock to human level intelligence, these are getting closer to human and further from rock and getting further from rock every day.