table stakes, but people still mess up on it constantly. The "yeah, but that's only a problem if you're an idiot" approach to this kind of thing hasn't served us very well so it's good to see something actually being done.

Trains shouldn't collide if the driver is correctly observing the signals, that's table stakes too. But rather than exclusively focussing on improving track to reduce derailments we also install train protection systems that automatically intervene when the driver does miss a signal. Cause that happens a lot more than a derailment. Even though "pay attention, see red signal? stop!" is conceptually super easy.

▲

q3k 5 hours ago | parent [-]

I'm not saying it's not important, it is. I just don't believe that '[the] majority of memory bugs are from out of bounds access'. That was maybe true 20 years ago, when an unbounded strcpy to an unprotected return pointer on the stack was super common and exploiting this kind of vulnerabilities what most vulndev was.

This brings C one tiny step closer to the state of the art, which is commendable, but I don't believe codebases which start using this will reduce their published vulnerability count significantly. Making use of this requires effort and diligence, and I believe most codebases that can expend such effort already have a pretty good security track record.

	▲	vlovich123 2 hours ago \| parent [-]
		The majority of security vulnerabilities in languages like C that aren’t memory safe are due to memory safety issues like UAF, buffer overflows etc etc. I don’t think I’ve seen finer grained research that tries to break it out by class of memory safety issue. The data is something like 80% of reported vulnerabilities in code written in these languages are due to memory safety issues. This doesn’t mean there aren’t other issues. It just means that it’s the cheapest exploit to search for when you are trying to break into a C/C++ service. And in terms of how easy it is to convert a memory safety issue into an exploit, it’s not meaningfully much harder. The harder pieces are when sandboxing comes into play so that for example exploiting V8 doesn’t give you arbitrary broader access if the compromised process is itself sandboxed.