Remix.run Logo
petesergeant 7 hours ago

Stoolap looks pretty interesting, anyone want to share their experience of using it?

gomoboo 7 hours ago | parent [-]

Never used it but I’ll chime in that the naming choice is unfortunate. For me as an English speaker it collides with stool, a term for excrement.

Aldipower 6 hours ago | parent | next [-]

So, what's an "ap" then? As a German speaker I am used to the word "stuhl" too. Which means both "stool" and also "chair". So I sit myself on stool every single day!

dspillett 2 hours ago | parent [-]

> I am used to the word "stuhl" too. Which means both "stool" and also "chair"

Stool means both stool (a backless chair, usually thought of as wooden with three or four fixed legs but the lack of back is the defining feature and those made of other materials and/or with more legs are still called stools) and stool (solid excrement, as in “stool sample”) in English too.

IIRC the something-to-sit-on meaning came directly from one of English's Germanic influences, we just use it for a different/specific kind of seat, and the association with excrement came either from toilet seats (privy stools) generally or the royal position “groom of the stool” (where it meant cleaning both the privy stool and the royal backside that made that need cleaning).

I wonder if the German language took the second meaning back from English later, or if they both developed at the same time for the same reason at a point when there was shared influence between English and German royal courts.

> So, what's an "ap" then?

In this context my mind went to application. StoolAp sounds like a digestive tracking “health management” tool someone with a scatological bent might have on their phone!

Aldipower 43 minutes ago | parent [-]

I had to look this very interesting word up now. And it is spread all around the Germanic languages and is directly derived from the verb "to stand" (en), "stehen" (de) or "at stå" (dk). Which is funny, because you sit on something that stands. :-)

> I wonder if the German language took the second meaning back from English later, or if they both developed at the same time for the same reason at a point when there was shared influence between English and German royal courts.

I would bet on the second one!

linesofcode 3 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Agreed but I did click on the post purely cause of its odd choice of name.

anonair 3 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Maybe sto-olap was meant by the authors?

murat3ok 40 minutes ago | parent [-]

Yes. Absolutely like this. Thank you for the correct usage.

bryanrasmussen 5 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

well I wouldn't pronounce it Stool - ap I would go with Stoo - lap. So people's chosen pronunciations may vary.