Remix.run Logo
rvz 7 hours ago

I think we have seen enough since the best example of a Rust browser that is Servo, has taken them 14 years to reach v0.0.1.

So the approach of having a new language that requires a full rewrite (even with an LLM) is still a bad approach.

Fil-C likely can do the job without a massive rewrite and achieving safety for C and C++.

Job done.

EDIT: The authors of Ladybird have already dismissed using Rust, and with Servo progressing at a slow pace it clearly shows that Ladybird authors do not want something like that to happen to the project.

tomjakubowski 6 hours ago | parent | next [-]

Until just a couple years ago, Servo had been a pure research project with no goal of ever releasing a full browser (and it was abandoned by Mozilla in 2020).

Igalia had five engineers working full time who turned that science project into v0.0.1 in less than two years.

josephg 6 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

> Fil-C likely can do the job without a massive rewrite and achieving safety for C and C++.

So long as you don't mind a 2-4x performance & memory usage cost.

satvikpendem 6 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Servo was essentially integrated into Firefox. It was not a browser in itself until it was put into a foundation on its own.

tvshtr 6 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

The RUST ecosystem barely just started getting into shape on the GUI toolkits frontend... So perhaps save your criticisms for something that wasn't born out of the vacuum.

bigyabai 6 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

> Fil-C likely can do the job

> Job done.

Seems like you forgot a few stops in your train of thought, Speed Racer.