It's not that they don't have a point, it's that everyone who's finding 4.6 to be fine or great are not running out to the internet to talk about it.

Being a moderately frequent user of Opus and having spoken to people who use it actively at work for automation, it's a really expensive model to run, I've heard it burn through a company's weekend's credit allocation before Saturday morning, I think using almost an order of magnitude more tokens is a valid consumer concern!

I have yet to hear anyone say "Opus is really good value for money, a real good economic choice for us". It seems that we're trying to retrofit every possible task with SOTA AI that is still severely lacking in solid reasoning, reliability/dependability, so we throw more money at the problem (cough Opus) in the hopes that it will surpass that barrier of trust.