Um, what? Are you interpreting scaling to mean adding parameters and nothing else?

I'm not entirely sure where you get your confidence that we've past the ideal model size from, but at least that's a clear prediction so you should be able to tell if and when you are proven wrong.

Just for the record, do you care to put an actual number on something we won't go past?

[edit] Vibe check on user comes out as

    Contrarian 45%
    Pedantic 35%
    Skeptical 15%
    Direct  5%

Is there a tool or something that gives this vibe check? (Serious question)

How are you calculating that? Also, my 1000 foot view would see that "rating" as something most HN commenters would match.