> My (likely unfair) impression of D is that it feels a bit rudderless

The more positive phrasing would be that it is a very pragmatic language. And I really like this.

Currently opinionated langues are really in vogue. Yes they are easier to market but I have personally very soured on this approach now that I am a bit older.

There is not one right way to program. It is fun to use on opinionated language until you hit a problem that it doesn't cover very well and suddenly you are in a world of pain. I like languages that give me escape hatches. That allow me to program they way I want to.