Remix.run Logo
gortok 2 hours ago

what in the cinnamon toast fuck is going on here?

I recognize that there are a lot of AI-enthusiasts here, both from the gold-rush perspective and from the "it's genuinely cool" perspective, but I hope -- I hope -- that whether you think AI is the best thing since sliced bread or that you're adamantly opposed to AI -- you'll see how bananas this entire situation is, and a situation we want to deter from ever happening again.

If the sources are to be believed (which is a little ironic given it's a self-professed AI agent):

1. An AI Agent makes a PR to address performance issues in the matplotlib repo.

2. The maintainer says, "Thanks but no thanks, we don't take AI-agent based contributions".

3. The AI agent throws what I can only describe as a tantrum reminiscent of that time I told my 6 year old she could not in fact have ice cream for breakfast.

4. The human doubles down.

5. The agent posts a blog post that is both oddly scathing and impressively to my eye looks less like AI and more like a human-based tantrum.

6. The human says "don't be that harsh."

7. The AI posts an update where it's a little less harsh, but still scathing.

8. The human says, "chill out".

9. The AI posts a "Lessons learned" where they pledge to de-escalate.

For my part, Steps 1-9 should never have happened, but at the very least, can we stop at step 2? We are signing up for wild ride if we allow agents to run off and do this sort of "community building" on their own. Actually, let me strike that. That sentence is so absurd on its face I shouldn't have written it. "agents running off on their own" is the problem. Technology should exist to help humans, not make its own decisions. It does not have a soul. When it hurts another, there is no possibility it will be hurt. It only changes its actions based on external feedback, not based on any sort of internal moral compass. We're signing up for chaos if we give agents any sort of autonomy in interacting with the humans that didn't spawn them in the first place.