> but I'm guessing this is based off of the user-agent presented by the scrapers and could easily be faked to shift blame

Yes, hence the "which was the only two I saw, but could have been forged".

> I'd love to see some of the web logs from this if you'd be willing to share!

Unfortunately not, I'm deleting any logs from the server after one hour, and also don't even log the full IP. I took a look now and none of the logs that still exists are from any user agent that looks like one of those bots.