The very fact that UTF-8 itself discouraged from using the BOM is just so alien to me. I understand they want it to be the last encoding and therefore not in need of a explicit indicator, but as it currently IS NOT the only encoding that is used, it makes is just so difficult to understand if I'm reading any of the weird ASCII derivatives or actual Unicode.

It's maddening and it's frustrating. The US doesn't have any of these issues, but in Europe, that's a complete mess!

▲ dspillett 5 hours ago | parent | next [-]

> The US doesn't have any of these issues

I think you mean “the US chooses to completely ignore these issues and gets away with it because they defined the basic standard that is used, ASCII, way-back-when, and didn't foresee it becoming an international thing so didn't think about anyone else” :)

▲ capitainenemo 7 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

From wikipedia...

    UTF-8 always has the same byte order,[5] so its only use in UTF-8 is to signal at the start that the text stream is encoded in UTF-8...
    Not using a BOM allows text to be backwards-compatible with software designed for extended ASCII. For instance many programming languages permit non-ASCII bytes in string literals but not at the start of the file. ...
   A BOM is unnecessary for detecting UTF-8 encoding. UTF-8 is a sparse encoding: a large fraction of possible byte combinations do not result in valid UTF-8 text.

That last one is a weaker point but it is true that with CSV a BOM is more likely to do harm, than good.

▲ g-b-r 7 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

Indeed, I've been using the BOM in all my text files for maybe decades now, those who wrote the recommendation are clearly from an English country

	▲	dspillett 5 hours ago \| parent [-]
		> are clearly from an English country One particular English-speaking country… The UK has issues with ASCII too, as our currently symbol (£) is not included. Not nearly as much trouble as non-English languages due to the lack of accents & such that they need, but we are still affected.