| ▲ | DonHopkins 2 hours ago | |
There's a fundamental architectural difference being missed here: MCP operates BETWEEN LLM complete calls, while skills operate DURING them. Every MCP tool call requires a full round-trip — generation stops, wait for external tool, start a new complete call with the result. N tool calls = N round-trips. Skills work differently. Once loaded into context, the LLM can iterate, recurse, compose, and run multiple agents all within a single generation. No stopping. No serialization. Skills can be MASSIVELY more efficient and powerful than MCP, if designed and used right. Leela MOOLLM Demo Transcript: https://github.com/SimHacker/moollm/blob/main/designs/LEELA-...
I call this "speed of light" as opposed to "carrier pigeon". In my experiments I ran 33 game turns with 10 characters playing Fluxx — dialogue, game mechanics, emotional reactions — in a single context window and completion call. Try that with MCP and you're making hundreds of round-trips, each suffering from token quantization, noise, and cost. Skills can compose and iterate at the speed of light without any detokenization/tokenization cost and distortion, while MCP forces serialization and waiting for carrier pigeons.speed-of-light skill: https://github.com/SimHacker/moollm/tree/main/skills/speed-o... Skills also compose. MOOLLM's cursor-mirror skill introspects Cursor's internals via a sister Python script that reads cursor's chat history and sqlite databases — tool calls, context assembly, thinking blocks, chat history. Everything, for all time, even after Cursor's chat has summarized and forgotten: it's still all there and searchable! cursor-mirror skill: https://github.com/SimHacker/moollm/tree/main/skills/cursor-... MOOLLM's skill-snitch skill composes with cursor-mirror for security monitoring of untrusted skills, also performance testing and optimization of trusted ones. Like Little Snitch watches your network, skill-snitch watches skill behavior — comparing declared tools and documentation against observed runtime behavior. skill-snitch skil: https://github.com/SimHacker/moollm/tree/main/skills/skill-s... You can even use skill-snitch like a virus scanner to review and monitor untrusted skills. I have more than 100 skills and had skill-snitch review each one including itself -- you can find them in the skill-snitch-report.md file of each skill in MOOLLM. Here is skill-snitch analyzing and reporting on itself, for example: skill-snitch's skill-snitch-report.md: https://github.com/SimHacker/moollm/blob/main/skills/skill-s... MOOLLM's thoughtful-commitment skill also composes with cursor-mirror to trace the reasoning behind git commits. thoughtful-commit skill: https://github.com/SimHacker/moollm/tree/main/skills/thought... MCP is still valuable for connecting to external systems. But for reasoning, simulation, and skills calling skills? In-context beats tool-call round-trips by orders of magnitude. | ||