The problem with this is that at the limit, this means "run the precommit on every save of a file," which is not really usually how people think of precommit hooks.

▲

rtpg 5 hours ago | parent [-]

Given jj's rebasing tooling, rewiring precommit into "prepush" feels like the right way forward. There's a bit of a phase transition between commits on your machine and commits that are out in the wild, after all.

▲

steveklabnik 4 hours ago | parent [-]

Maybe! I agree that it feels kinda better. I’m not a huge hook user personally though.

	▲	rtpg an hour ago \| parent [-]
		For me it's mostly about doing as much of CI locally as feels reasonable to do quickly to save an iteration cycle. But I live in a world of badly configured text editors and the like so I usually have some silly formatting error