Remix.run Logo
TaupeRanger 14 hours ago

Lots of very scared, angry developers in these comment sections recently...

hollowturtle 14 hours ago | parent | next [-]

Not angry nor scared, I value my hard skills a lot, I'm just wondering why people believe religiously everything AI related. Maybe I'm a bit sick with the excessive hype

hollowturtle 14 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Also note that I'm a heavy LLM user, not anti ai for sure

crystal_revenge 8 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

There's no fear (a bit of anger I must admit). I suspect nearly all of the reaction against this comes from a similar place to where mine does:

All of the real world code I have had to review created by AI is buggy slop (often with subtle, but weird bugs that don't show up for a while). But on HN I'm told "this is because your co-workers don't know how to AI right!!!!" Then when someone who supposedly must be an expert in getting things done with AI posts, it's always big claims with hand-wavy explanations/evidence.

Then the comments section is littered with no effort comments like this.

Yet oddly whenever anyone asks "show me the thing you built?" Either it looks like every other half-working vibe coded CRUD app... or it doesn't exist/can't be shown.

If you tell me you have discovered a miracle tool, just some me the results. Not taking increasingly ridiculous claims at face value is not "fear". What I don't understand is where comments like yours come from? What makes you need this to be more than it is?

Banditoz 8 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

This is extremely reductive and incredibly dismissive of everything they wrote above.

crystal_revenge 8 hours ago | parent [-]

It's because they don't have a substantive response to it, so they resort to ad hominems.

I've worked extensively in the AI space, and believe that it is extremely useful, but these weird claims (even from people I respect a lot) that "something big and mysterious is happening, I just can't show you yet!" set of my alarms.

When sensible questions are met with ad hominems by supporters it further sets of alarm bells.

thr59182617 12 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

I see way more hype that is boosted by the moderators. The scared ones are the nepo babies who founded a vaporware AI company that will be bought by daddy or friends through a VC.

They have to maintain the hype until a somewhat credible exit appears and therefore lash out with boomer memes, FOMO, and the usual insane talking points like "there are builders and coders".

simianwords 11 hours ago | parent [-]

i'm not sure what kind of conspiracy you are hallucinating. do you think people have to "maintain the hype"? it is doing quite well organically.

hollowturtle 11 hours ago | parent [-]

So well that they're losing billions and OpenAI may go bankrupt this year

simianwords 11 hours ago | parent [-]

what if it doesn't?

hollowturtle 11 hours ago | parent [-]

better for them! the heck i care about it