Remix.run Logo
materialpoint 5 hours ago

How is that different from today's SA, like CodeQL and SonarQube? Most of the feedback is just sh*t and drives programmers towards making senseless perfections that just double the amount of work had to be done later to toggle or tune behaviour, because the configurable variables are gone due to bad static code analysis. Clearly present intent and convience like: Making a method virtual, adding a public method, not making a method static when it is likely to use instance fields in the future --- these good practices are shunned in all SA just because the rules are opportunistic, not real.

shakna 5 hours ago | parent [-]

My experience at work: Claude regularly says to use one method over another, because it's "safer"... But the method doesn't actually exist in that language. Seems to get rather confused between C# and C++, despite also getting told the language, before and after getting handed the code.