I see a second round of legislation might be needed. They'll get it right eventually.

input_sh 6 hours ago | parent | next [-]

Eh, there's no specific definition of interoperability written in the Digital Markets Act. It's decided on a case-by-case basis and I'm sure that the legislators in charge of this case will push back on this piss-poor implementation in like a year from now.

By the time this back-and-forth reaches its end, these two will find some shady b2b customers and are gonna be touted as "successful European startups".

▲

Bratmon 6 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

They never got cookie popups right. What makes you so confident?

▲

jorvi 6 hours ago | parent | next [-]

They got cookie pop-ups right, current rules:

- the default choice needs to be "strictly necessary cookies

- with other less prominent buttons for "allow all" and "deny all"

- a site is not allowed to force you to have the press a bunch of buttons or select a bunch of things to deny most/all cookies

The problem lies in enforcement. Unless you are a huge player, there is almost nil chance you're gonna get fined.

I think about the only thing missing is that they should have RFC'd a standard akin to Do Not Track, except this would have communicated to sites if your default is "strictly necessary", "allow all" or"deny all". With it being set to "strictly necessary" by default.

▲

palata 5 hours ago | parent [-]

> The problem lies in enforcement. Unless you are a huge player, there is almost nil chance you're gonna get fined.

I am curious: why is that difficult? Define the fine as a percentage of the revenue of the company, have users report links, and pay someone to check the link and send the fine.

Sounds like easy money... I mean it's very profitable to pay people to check parking lots and fine drivers who don't follow the regulations. This should be even more profitable?

▲

xmcp123 2 hours ago | parent [-]

If I am business outside Europe, why would I send Europe what my revenue is?

	▲	direwolf20 18 minutes ago \| parent [-]
		I don't know — why do businesses outside Europe care about GDPR compliance at all? They could just track you without any cookie banners.

▲

kubb 6 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

Optimistic. They've got sideloading done, browser and search choice done, ad transparency done, more choice for payments done, many dark patterns banned.

The gears are turning slowly, but they're doing really useful work.